The Alienist by Caleb Carr is a historical crime thriller set in 1896 New York City. It follows Dr. Laszlo Kreizler, a psychologist (referred to as an “alienist” in that era), and his team, which includes reporter John Schuyler Moore and Sara Howard, one of the city’s first female detectives. They are enlisted by then-Police Commissioner Theodore Roosevelt to track down a brutal serial killer preying on young male prostitutes. Using emerging techniques like psychological profiling and forensic science, the group delves into the mind of the killer, uncovering dark secrets while facing resistance from corrupt officials and society. The novel explores themes of mental illness, morality, and the complexities of justice.
This is a book that I think would benefit more from being told in the third-person perspective than in the first-person perspective. Usually, when you are telling the story from the first-person perspective, you can really feel a connection to the character, but here it was the complete opposite. I felt absolutely nothing towards the main character. I saw another review refer to John Moore as an observer, and I think that’s the perfect way to put it rather than him being a player in this plot. All of the characters were developed. This is one of the most developed casts of characters I’ve seen, but again, I did not feel a connection towards these people.
Atmosphere is definitely one of the highlights. I loved that we are in New York City, a city that is still in a way similar because the street names are the same. The neighborhoods are in relatively the same locations, so you have an idea of what the modern place looks like, but then put all the smog and dirt on top of that and you’re going to have your 1896 setting. There was so much research put into the setting and getting those exact street names and those exact locations. It was so easy to picture. This book was full of descriptions.
The writing was very descriptive, as I said. I never felt bogged down, though, or that it was too much or over the top. The chapters were relatively short for the most part; only a handful went on a bit too long. In those chapters that did go on so long, I have no idea how the author expects us to remember every bit of dialogue that went on. However, this book did go by relatively fast, even though it was 600 pages, but the short chapters were a lifesaver.
I’m not really a thriller person, but I did find this book to be extremely interesting. It was incredibly logical; there were no loose ends, and everything was happening for a reason, rather than for shock value. This is the deepest thriller I’ve ever read. It may be the smartest thriller I’ve ever read. There’s so much depth to the story. One of the main themes here is that people are complex. There is context to why a person is the way they are—a person isn’t just born being a killer or being evil. Things lead up to them being the way that they are, things that usually happened in their childhood. This book really shows what makes a killer. Those are great themes, and there is so much logic throughout the 600 pages, but it was lacking intrigue. I found myself getting bored and just not caring. Overall, this is still a good book. There’s a lot of depth, and it was smart. I would recommend picking it up if you’re interested.
3.5 out of 5 stars.
Izzy Reads 