
“A romance writer who no longer believes in love and a literary writer stuck in a rut engage in a summer-long challenge that may just upend everything they believe about happily ever afters.”
The characters had so much potential. They had their baggage and trauma a.k.a. layers. They had depth, but I lacked an emotional connection to them. Isn’t romance built on emotion? As the book went on, I grew frustrated with January, the female main character. She was so in her head. Sure, dating does come with its anxieties, however, there wasn’t enough evidence here for her to feel that way, but again anxiety is irrational, but it was frustrating to read. She read as someone who was angry and irritable, and she also had a habit of overreacting. This is a romance, but I didn’t feel the chemistry between the two characters.
The title of the book falls loosely to the setting. I’ll explain more later. I loved Pete’s house and the whimsy cozy grandma vibe that it had. That part of the setting reminded me of ‘Practical Magic’. This is a slow building story with long chapters, but it reads quickly. There were some beautiful reflective passages about love and romance, and how we can have a struggle in our life, but there is always something good waiting for us.
I love that the book centers on two creatives who bounce ideas off each other. Their creative process was so fun to witness. I love to see how other creative people think. I really enjoyed those scenes.
My main takeaway is that the beach read or romance, as a genre in general, is legit. A lot of people look down on romance, but this book proved why the genre is so popular. In this world we need something to smile at and a sense of control knowing what will happen. With a romance book there’s a formula, you know there’s going to be a happy ending. You can control these 300 pages knowing what is going to happen when outside of that book this world is full of uncertainty. These kinds of stories can give someone peace of mind. This is also a story of making the best of what you have. Learning to dance in the rain, if you will.
As I didn’t have a connection to the characters or felt the romance blossom between them, there wasn’t a whole lot of intrigue within these pages. I was going along with the notions, but this was perfect for me to read on vacation because of that. The book lacked logic as I didn’t understand the thought process of,the character,of January. This was a good book. It got the job done for me. Emily Henry is a five star author, I know this potential in this book did blossom into a great book. If this is one that you want to read, I would still give it a go because it is so popular and from a good author.
3 out of 5 stars.






